A
TWO month public consultation has started over controversial proposals
to close Kinneil Museum in Bo’ness.
In February, Falkirk Council revealed
plans to close the historic building and transfer part of its
collection to a refurbished Hippodrome Cinema in Bo’ness town
centre. Officials suggested that Kinneil’s Roman display would
be moved to Callendar House in Falkirk.
The move prompted criticism from locals
and heritage groups. (Read our timeline below)
The Council has now launched an official
consultation period, and is asking for comments. The talks end
on June 30.
In a press statement just posted on the
Council’s website, the council said it was proposing “various
changes to the way Kinneil Museum is operated” – but didn’t
elaborate on the proposals.
Councillor Robert Spears, convener of
the council’s environment and heritage committee, said: “We
recognise that there is great public feeling about the future
of Kinneil Museum and we want to hear as many opinions as possible
on its future. We also want to find out what people think of our
plans for the Hippodrome and to give the local community a chance
to be involved in its development.
”We intend to contact a large number
of community based organisations to take on board their views
as well as welcoming individual comments made by the public.
”These views will be considered and
we will report back the findings to a meeting of the Environment
and Heritage Committee later in the summer.”
”It’s important that local residents
have their say over this issue and we are offering them a real
opportunity to voice their opinions.”
Those wishing to make their thoughts
known can do so in a variety of ways including:
TIMELINE
May 2003 – Museum official steps
down
Jack Sanderson, the Falkirk Council official
responsible for the development of Kinneil Museum, retires from
the Council. “Today, there's too much red tape,” he tells
the Bo’ness Journal.
Read the Journal
story here
Late 2005 - Falkirk Council publishes
its draft heritage strategy.
The draft strategy proposes a “review”
of all the council’s museums in the district (including Kinneil
Museum) – with one exception. The Council says it wants to “improve
facilities and operations management to enhance our custodianship
of Callendar House” in Falkirk.
Read
the draft heritage strategy here
February 14, 2006 – Report to
council’s environment and heritage committee first reveals proposal
to close Kinneil Museum.
Read
the council report, including the proposals, here.
February 14, 2006 – Falkirk
Council puts out a press statement on the plans.
“It is hoped the refurbished Hippodrome
building will become the new home of the exhibitions at both Bo’ness
Town Hall and Kinneil Museum bringing them together, for the first
time, under the one roof. A community consultation is planned
to take place prior to work getting underway in May 2007.”
Read
the council press statement here
February 17, 2006 – Bo’ness
Journal reports the Kinneil closure plans tied in with the re-opening
of the Hippodrome Cinema.
The paper talks to Bo’ness Councillor
John Constable. The paper claims: “Councillor Constable conceded
that closure of Kinneil Museum was regrettable. He added: ‘It
has a diminishing footfall but the many fine exhibits deserve
greater exposure.’.”
Read
the Journal story here
February 22 or 23, 2006 – Falkirk
Council issues a statement to the Journal.
Sue Selwyn, the Council’s head of culture
and lifelong learning, says in the statement: “The Environment
and Heritage Committee agreed to recommend the transfer of the
museum function to the Hippodrome and also to consult with the
community on future uses of the museum and its collections in
the coming months.”
Read
her full statement to the paper here.
February 24, 2006 – Journal reports
anger at the closure plans for Kinneil Museum – using the headline
“Sneak thieves”.
The paper reflects on Ms Selwyn’s statement
and suggests: “Local folk are right to be fearful for the
museum's future.”
Read
the Journal story here
March 3, 2006 – Community council
reveals plans to discuss the proposed closure of Kinneil Museum
at its March meeting.
The Journal also reveals an online poll
run by www.bo-ness.org.uk
showed 90 per cent of respondents against removal of part of Kinneil’s
displays to Falkirk.
Read
the Journal story here
March 8, 2006 – Falkirk Council’s
policy and resources committee meets.
The policy committee backs the recommend-ations
in the February 14th report on the Hippodrome/Kinneil
Museum (see above to download) – but stresses there will
be full consultation.
A bid to remove the threat of closure
from Kinneil Museum is overturned.
Read
the official minute of the committee here, noting the decisions.
March 9, 2006 – Around 50 people
attend the community council meeting on Kinneil Museum.
A show of hands reveals unanimous support
for the museum to be retained. Councillor Constable claims there
has been “misinformation” about the council’s plans,
but pledges that the Bo’ness people – no-one else – will make
the decision about the museum’s future.
March 11, 2006 – “Hands
off our museum”. The Journal reports on the community meeting.
Kate Erskine, a former museum employee,
is quoted as saying: "When I started work there in 1987
Kinneil Museum was a thriving and worthwhile place. Closure would
be a barrier to learning about our history.''
Read
the Journal story here
March 11, 2006 – Councillor
Constable sends a letter to the Bo’ness website confirming:
“The Bo’ness public would decide whether the Kinneil Museum
was closed or not.”
Download
Councillor Constable’s letter here.
March 17, 2006 – Petition plea
A schoolboy gathers 160 signatures urging
Falkirk Council not to close the museum. His mother says: “More
needs to be done to improve Kinneil Estate for visitors.”
Read
the Journal story here
March 30, 2006 – A senior councillor
tries to re-assure worried residents.
Councillor Robert Spears told The Falkirk
Herald: "There are a lot of plans being looked at and we're
very open to people's ideas as well. Ultimately, the heritage
sites and collections in the Falkirk area don't belong to the
council, they belong to the people."
Read
The Falkirk Herald story
April 9, 2006 – “Fury as
Antonine Museum set to go to the Wall”.
Roman re-enactment group the Antonine
Guard pledge their support for the campaign to save the Museum.
Its secretary tells the Sunday Express: “Kinneil Museum should
be upgraded and not shut.”
April 14, 2006 – “Fighting
talk”
The Journal reports on the Antonine
Guard’s fight to retain Kinneil Museum. It also reveals a new
group, Friends of Kinneil, has been set up to promote and develop
Kinneil Estate.
Read
the Journal story here
April 14, 2006 – “Fighting
talk”
The Bo’ness Journal reports on the history
of Kinneil Estate. It says the general view of Falkirk Council’s
stewardship of Kinneil Estate is: “Under-funded, under-promoted
and under-used.”
Read
the Journal story here
April 21, 2006 – “Don’t
make our museum history”.
A petition is launched to get Falkirk
Council to keep Kinneil Museum open. Lynn Munro of Friends of
Kinneil tells the Journal: “To think that the council wants
to close the door on a museum, which stands on land gifted by
Robert the Bruce himself, is incomprehensible."
Read
the Journal story here
April 21, 2006 – Former boss
speaks out.
Jack Sanderson, the former cultural
services manager at Falkirk Council, writes to the Journal and
Gazette. In his letter, he says: “The exciting story of Kinneil
Estate can only be experienced on site and the museum is a vital
starting point.”
The paper says it received a huge number
of letters about the museum. (This
letter is no longer online).
April 25, 2006 – Council to
start consultation.
Falkirk Council issues a press release
on its plans for Kinneil Museum . . . but fails to clarify its
proposals.
Read the council
press release here
May 1, 2006 – Consultation gets
underway
May 18, 2006 – Area Forum to
discuss Kinneil.
The Bo’ness Area Forum will discuss
the closure plans at a meeting on Thursday,
May 18, in Kinneil School, starting at 7 p.m.
If you want to speak out on
this topic, make sure you’re there . . . .